Sponsored by BRS Backyard Bug Busters
Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak is a restaurant in West Milford, NJ. Open: Mon Closed; Tue–Thu 4:00 – 10:00 PM; Fri 4:00 – 11:00 PM; Sat 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM; Sun 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM. Phone: (973) 728-9613. Average rating is 4.6 stars from 166 reviews. Website: https://www.prime374.com/.
Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak
Call Now Directions
Review
Elegant dining area with large windows and stylish decor. — Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak
4.6 166 reviews Today 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM

Prime Cuts. Fresh Catch. West Milford's Table.

Steakhouse-quality beef and ocean-fresh seafood served six nights a week on Morsetown Road.

About Us

Interior view of Prime 374 restaurant with tables set for dining. — Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak
Interior view of Prime 374 restaurant with tables set for dining.

The address is right there in the name. 374 Morsetown Road is where West Milford comes to eat seriously, whether that means a dry-aged ribeye with a proper crust or a whole branzino that arrived from the dock that morning. The room earns its name: this is a Prime experience, not a shortcut one.

The dining room has hosted everything from quiet date nights to full rehearsal dinners for families who came in once, liked what they found, and booked the private space before the check hit the table. A 4.6-star rating across 166 reviews tells you the kitchen is consistent enough to bring people back a second and third time.

The kitchen closes late on weekends and opens for lunch on Saturday and Sunday, giving you a reason to make the drive out Morsetown regardless of the occasion. Closed Mondays, open to business every other night of the week.

What We Offer

The menu divides cleanly between land and sea, and both sides get equal attention. On the steak side, expect USDA Prime and choice cuts cooked to temperature with the kind of char that only a high-heat broiler produces. Porterhouses, filets, and bone-in ribeyes anchor the menu, each paired with sides built to match the weight of the plate.

The seafood program is just as deliberate. Lobster, scallops, fresh fish preparations, and shellfish options rotate with availability, so the menu reflects what is actually good rather than what is always convenient. Sauces and preparations lean classic without being stiff.

For groups, the private dining option handles rehearsal dinners, anniversaries, milestone birthdays, and corporate events. The space seats parties comfortably and the team coordinates the details so the host can actually enjoy the evening.

Gallery

Take a look at our space and what we have to offer

What Our Customers Say

Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers

Click to Rate & Review This Business ✍️
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 months ago
"After eating here in January, to check out the restaurant, and inquire about having a private event, we had our son and his fiancee's rehearsal dinner at Prime 374. The venue was, in my opinion, outstanding in every way. The food was delicious, the service was very good and the atmosphere was wonderful. Everyone who attended raved about all of the above. Thank you to the team at Prime 374 for making a special night so memorable. I will definitely come back to dine here again. Highly recommended."
— Mighty Quinn
a month ago
"We honestly had to laugh because the experience was so bad. This place is supposed to be fine dining, yet the service and food were unbelievably disappointing all around. Not really sure how this place has 4.7 stars. The restaurant wasn’t even busy — maybe 10 tables max — yet it took nearly 20 minutes just to get drinks and 1 hour and 15 minutes for appetizers. We constantly had to wave the waiter down because he barely checked on us. The lobster bisque and vegetable soup were the same exact soup, except one had about three tiny pieces of lobster tossed in. My soup even had a coagulated film across the top like it had been sitting under a heat lamp for that hour and a half. The appetizers were wrong — cold clams instead of baked clams — and we got this sad “1.5 pieces of bacon” situation. Then our pasta order was wrong too. We ordered Cherry’s spicy chicken penne and got plain penne vodka instead. The steak ordered medium came out really rare. Honestly, everything was blah, which is crazy considering the bill was $650. For that kind of money, the meal and experience should’ve been incredible. And don’t get me started on the lack of landscaping. Unless that’s the vibe they are going for …rundown? Buy a lawn mower. lol! First and last time here."
— Kristy Bond
⭐⭐
4 months ago
"My partner and I discovered this restaurant a few months ago, decided to give it a try and loved the food. So much so we came back a second and third time. Unfortunately though, the last visit wasn’t good at all, we came, was taken to our tables and ordered water as our beverage and had to wait over 30 minutes for just that. But that wasn’t the worst part, there were times the host wasn’t busy and even looked at us, I made sure to make eye contact with him, and hadn’t come to bring us our water (tap at that). This went on longer than it should. We had to ask another host for water and another for bread being it was a bit of a drive and we were a bit hungry. The host that bought us bread, (not our initial host) was another that was kind enough to ask if we wanted some and brought us the bread and oil but our main host just kept pretending like he didn’t notice us until it got to a point where we were almost having a staring contest and had to call him out. After finally getting our order taken, we waited over 45 minutes for that just to come out, by then I had already lost my appetite because of the service. Another thing I noticed, this is the only restaurant I’ve ever been to that switches its hosts midway through serving you. The first time we came, that happened and I believe the third time as well. But the last visit is why I’m giving this place two stars. The having us wait, was most definitely intentional given there were multiple occasions where we locked eyes with our host and saw he was not doing anything at all. I mentioned to my partner that I noticed this about him the first time he served us but I believe in letting things show in a pattern before I make any speculations and our last visit confirmed it. It was very unwelcoming and impolite, will not be running back to this restaurant any time soon."
— Brina
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
a month ago
"We visited Prime 374 last Saturday night. The entire experience was phenomenal; from the delicious drinks prepared by a very knowledgable and talented bartender, to the wonderful, attentive service, to the absolutely delicious meal. The ambiance was very warm and cozy and made you feel at home. We cannot wait to go back!!"
— Jeanne Lewit
a month ago
"Should have realized when we pulled in and the grass was nearly five inches tall and full of dandelions that this was not the right choice. Reservation at 5 pm. No drinks offered until we asked at 5:40. Appetizer finally started to arrive after we were obviously looking around at 6:15. Messed up order and food was mediocre. Entrees were blah. Steak was BLUE - even manager realized it was raw. Staff stands around. Oh, the Canadian bacon appetizer- 1 1/2 slices?? What happened to the other half???? Drove too far to be so disappointed and pay so much!"
— Laurie Lombardi

Frequently Asked Questions

What are Prime 374's hours?

Prime 374 is open Tuesday through Thursday from 4:00 to 10:00 PM, Friday from 4:00 to 11:00 PM, Saturday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM. The restaurant is closed on Mondays.

Does Prime 374 offer private dining for events?

Yes. The restaurant has hosted rehearsal dinners, anniversary celebrations, and private parties. Contact them directly through prime374.com to discuss availability, capacity, and menu options for your event.

Is Prime 374 a fine dining restaurant?

Prime 374 positions itself as an upscale steakhouse and seafood destination. The menu, pricing, and room reflect a special-occasion dining experience, though the atmosphere is approachable enough for a well-dressed weeknight dinner.

Does the menu focus more on steak or seafood?

Both receive serious attention. The kitchen runs a full steakhouse program alongside a dedicated seafood menu with lobster, scallops, fresh fish, and shellfish options. You can order from either side or mix across the table.

Do I need a reservation?

For weekend evenings and private events, a reservation is strongly recommended. You can check availability and book through the website at prime374.com.

Where exactly is Prime 374 located?

The restaurant is at 374 Morsetown Road in West Milford, NJ 07480. It sits in the West Milford area of Passaic County, easily accessible from surrounding northern New Jersey communities.

Does Prime 374 serve lunch?

Lunch service is available on Saturday and Sunday, with doors opening at 11:00 AM on both days. Tuesday through Friday service begins at 4:00 PM.

Hours of Operation

Closed · Opens 11:00 AM
Monday Closed
Tuesday 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Wednesday 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Thursday 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Friday 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Saturday Today 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
72° Clear West Milford
Sat 93° 71°
Sun 87° 68°
Mon 69° 64°
Tue 70° 58°
Wed 83° 57°
Thu 88° 63°
Fri 83° 65°

Get In Touch

Ready to get started? Contact us today!

Save to Contacts

More places nearby

Other restaurant spots near here. Tap one to open its page.

Cuban Restaurant ★ 4.6 (70)
Cuban Breeze
3055 NJ-23, Oak Ridge, NJ 07438
Restaurant ★ 4.8 (128)
Cibo e Vino Ristorante
216 Cahill Cross Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480
Restaurant ★ 4.1 (1,909)
Mason Jar Family Restaurant and Bar
219 Ramapo Valley Rd, Mahwah, NJ 07430
$$

Contact Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak

Send a note and Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak will get back to you. No account needed.

Add an email or a phone so they can reply.

Best time to reach you

Report an issue

See something off? Tell us. We’ll fix it and improve the listing for everyone. No account required.